Bollywood films have often been a source of entertainment and cultural representation, but they have occasionally faced criticism for their portrayal of sensitive subjects. Bawaal, a recent Bollywood film directed by Nitesh Tiwari, has become the centre of controversy due to its handling of the Holocaust, one of history's most tragic events.
Starring Janhvi Kapoor and Varun Dhawan, the film revolves around a love story that intertwines with the couple's visit to World War II sites, including Auschwitz, leading to severe backlash from critics and the Jewish community.
Bawaal follows the story of a small-town school teacher and his arranged match, a woman with epilepsy. As the couple embarks on a journey to Europe, visiting World War II sites, they slowly fall in love. However, the film garnered severe backlash due to its portrayal of their visits to Holocaust sites and using Auschwitz as a metaphor for relationship troubles. In particular, one scene, set in a gas chamber, features the male lead saying, "We're all a little like Hitler, aren't we?" about human dissatisfaction.
The Simon Wiesenthal Centre, an organisation dedicated to protecting the human rights of the Jewish community, strongly criticised the film. They called on Amazon Prime Video, where this film was released, to remove Bawaal from its platform, citing its "outlandish abuse of the Nazi Holocaust as a plot device." Rabbi Abraham Cooper, an associate dean and director of Global Social Action at the NGO, emphasised that "Auschwitz is not a metaphor" and
condemned the trivialisation of the suffering and murder of millions of Holocaust victims.
The film's release sparked widespread criticism, with many viewers and critics accusing Bawaal of normalising Hitler's rule and displaying poor taste. Some took to social media to express their concerns, questioning how such content was problematic. The film's lead star, Varun Dhawan, defended the film, pointing out the unequal scrutiny and morality applied to non-Hindi language films, explicitly mentioning a scene in Christopher Nolan's Oppenheimer.
In that scene, Hindu right-wing groups in India raised objections. However, the criticism against "Bawaal" persisted, with many arguing that Bollywood must address its sensitivity problem and avoid trivialising significant historical events. Despite the film's intentions, the Holocaust remains a subject that demands the utmost respect and sensitivity.
Recently, Bollywood has grappled with a creativity crisis despite having renowned directors, substantial budgets, and the industry's biggest superstars. The film fraternity needs to work on producing original and innovative ideas, needing more fresh and compelling storytelling. Audiences are increasingly voicing their discontent with the prevalence of remakes, sequels, and formulaic plots, which has led to a sense of stagnation in the industry. In stark contrast, South Indian cinema, particularly movies like Baahubali and RRR, has been thriving and garnering international acclaim.
RRR achieved a remarkable feat by bagging the Oscar for India in 2023, a testimony to the fresh perspectives and original narratives explored in the South film industry. As Bollywood faces this challenge, filmmakers must break free from the safety of familiar tropes and embrace the spirit of creativity to once again capture the hearts of their audience.
Auschwitz, the most prominent and notorious concentration camp established by Nazi Germany during World War II, is a haunting reminder of the atrocities committed during the Holocaust. Located in southern Poland, Auschwitz comprised three main camps: Auschwitz I, Auschwitz II-Birkenau, and Auschwitz III-Monowitz. Originally built to house Polish political prisoners, Auschwitz evolved into a site of mass murder and extermination, where over 1.1 million people, mostly Jews, were brutally killed.
The camp's grim history involved forced labour, inhumane living conditions, and the systematic extermination of millions in gas chambers. Today, Auschwitz serves as a solemn memorial and museum, preserving past horrors as a testament to the importance of remembering and learning from one of humanity's darkest chapters.
During World War II, the Nazis used Auschwitz as a central hub for their genocidal campaign against European Jews. Upon arrival, prisoners were subjected to a ruthless selection process, with those deemed fit for labour temporarily spared. At the same time, the elderly, children, and infirm were sent directly to the gas chambers. The killings at Auschwitz reached horrifying proportions, with thousands of victims perishing daily.
The camp's operations extended to grotesque medical experiments led by the notorious Josef Mengele and the use of prisoners for forced labour in nearby factories. When the Soviet Red Army liberated the camp in January 1945, the world was confronted with the full extent of the Holocaust's barbarity, leaving an indelible mark on history and human conscience.
The film's controversy highlights the need for cultural sensitivity and historical awareness in filmmaking. While creative expression is crucial, it must be balanced with respect for sensitive historical events. Nitesh Tiwari is a celebrated director in Indian cinema, he has made Dangal, Chhichhore, and Nil Battey Sannata. These movies have gained widespread popularity commercially also.
The Simon Wiesenthal Centre's call for the film's removal from streaming platforms raises important questions about the responsibility of filmmakers in handling delicate historical subjects. As we continue to appreciate cinema's power to entertain and educate, we must remember the significance of preserving historical truths and promoting empathy in storytelling.
Share This Post On
Leave a comment
You need to login to leave a comment. Log-in